Holy Cow
Book - 2015


Opinion
From the critics

Community Activity
Summary
Add a SummaryThis book is written from the perspective of a very insightful cow. No really her name is Elsie she is a milk cow and it is about her adventures through the barn yard.
Elsie, a regular cow on the farm always had a normal life until one day she realized something big. One night, she snuck out of her pen and caught the kids watching TV. She watched too and discovered that animals on the farm get killed for meat. So she decides to escape from the barn and to india
A cow named Elsie runs away from her farm—along with a turkey and a pig—in order to avoid being sacrificed for meat.
Elsie the cow is happy Iiving on the farm until she learns the truth about the eventual fate of farm animals. She teams up with Tom the turkey and Shalom the pig to try and escape doom and find Utopia. None of it goes as planned, but the all manage to live happily ever after.

From the actor best known as Mulder from The X-Files comes a debut novel that could start out as a joke: A cow, a pig and a turkey walk off of a farm… David Duchovny’s acerbic style is fully present as he presents this tale of modern bovine woe.
Elsie is a smart-alecky cow leading a pretty idyllic life (with very decided opinions on the other farm animals) until “the event” that changes her future. Upon learning that farm animals are raised to be slaughtered and eaten by the humans that (she thought) cared for them, Elsie and her pals Shalom the pig (formerly known as Jerry until he converted to Judaism) and Tom the turkey set out for lands more hospitable to their individual natures: Tom is off to Turkey, Shalom is set on Israel where pork is a no-no, and Elsie is going where cows are revered, not eaten – India.
The ways and means by which a turkey, pig and cow make it to Turkey, Israel and India requires them walking on two legs, some shady disguises, a circumcision, an iPhone, some guidance from Joe Camel in Palestine, and last but not least suspension of disbelief of enormous proportions. But with tongue fully planted in cheek they all get there in the end, and along the way Elsie throws the following issues into her readers’ faces – big agri-business, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and the legitimization of drugs, among others. Of course each meets their own Promised Land with trepidation and ultimately reality collides with their dreams in some hilariously disappointing ways.
Duchovny and his cow Elsie may not solve all the world’s problems with this novel but they certainly hold a mirror up to some of its more ridiculous facets, and allows us to laugh – albeit ruefully - at ourselves for our role in them.
Quotes
Add a QuoteWhen I awoke the middle child was milking me. I must have been awake before that, but I was kind of sleepwalking, half of me could not stop thinking of what I'd seen, which left only half of me to be awake and conscious and make my way through the day.
“You humans drink our milk and eat the eggs of the chickens and the ducks. Isn't that enough for you? Isn't it enough that we give you our children and what's meant for our children? And if not, when is it enough? All you humans do is take, take, take from the earth and its beautiful creatures, and what do you give back? Nothing. I know humans consider it a grave insult to be called an animal. Well, I would never give a human the fine distinction of being called an animal, because an animal may kill to live but an animal never lives to kill. Humans have to earn the right to be called animals again.”

Now personally, I think it's a little weird to drink another animal's milk. You don't see me walking up to some human lady who just gave birth, saying, "Yo, can I get a taste?" -Elsie the Cow
Notices
Add NoticesAge Suitability
Add Age Suitability
Comment
Add a CommentIn the recent past vegetarianism and the pull of finding your place in the narrative of what to eat has been strong. But this book is not that. This book is not a preaching or argumentative but rather just a story to make you think beyond yourself. But it isn't even about that either. It is about searching for your place in the world and discovering it may have been where you were in the first place. It is a book about how we are all connected whatever our race, culture, or species. "We are all animals." This book is one where you use your own experiences to read between the lines.. but the fact remains we all just want to exist and belong.
There's a lot I didn't like about Red Notice to the point that I almost gave up halfway through. I'm so glad I didn't though because the second half completely changed my mind and made Browder's book one that won't ever leave my thoughts.
Red Notice is the non-fiction (& memoir**) written by Bill Browder, one of the first Western investors in Eastern Europe, and his experience fighting corruption in Russia. Browder's fight escalated dangerously into a Russian ban, murdered colleagues, an Interpol Red Notice (or international arrest warrant), and most famously the passing of the US Magnitsky Act. You've probably heard of the Magnitsky Act recently in the news, as the "Trump Tower meeting" was set up by Russians to lobby against this law. Reading this book will give you great context for all the recent developments in US-Russian relations and I was incredibly moved learning about the bill's namesake, lawyer Sergei Magnitsky.
All of the above comes from the excellent second half of the book. The first half, however, is not good. Instead of great nonfiction, the first half reads more like a memoir on Browder's life. We read about his childhood at boarding school, college, his marriages, including the courtship of his current wife, and all other very uninteresting and beside the point aspects of his life. At least he keeps it succinct, which is the only thing that allowed me to keep going. What I most hated, however, is the shallow writing in the first half of the book. Browder comes off as insulting and arrogant when he describes every person he comes across by their "crooked teeth," "plumpness," or other equally unnecessary slights. If you can get through the first half, you will be rewarded with a moving, intriguing, and inspiring story of fighting for justice in the second half.
A different sort of a story. I enjoyed the off-beat humour, I guess it is loosely, a book about growing up. The book is entertaining, with witty comments by the three main characters...Elsie, the cow, Shalom the pig (who converted to Judaism) and Tom the Turkey (who can use an iPhone with his beak). Illustrations are used in the book. The author indicated that he wrote the book for his son. The themes would be more suited to an older teenage audience.
Actual rating: 2.25 stars
(I made it up to page 164 and stopped.)
When I first picked up this book, the plot and premise really intrigued me. I was anticipating for a great story, but as the story dragged on, it made me weary.
The beginning part, when Elsie was still on the farm, was rather likeable for me. I actually really enjoyed the screenplay-like format for the dialogue. Things were straightforward and easy to follow up with.
Then, things started going in different directions. Right when Elsie and Tom and Shalom's trip began, the story began to bore me. This was supposed to be the journey, but I wasn't interested. Shalom's constant Yiddish vocabulary was really annoying, and the author began inserting way too many references and allusions. It became harder to read and less enjoyable for me.
So, overall, there was a great proposition for this story, but the writing was incapable of living up to it. Rather disappointing.
Fun book of life from a cow's perspective. I read this to my 7 year old and he loved it. It has moments of sadness or hatred for human kind (as any cow would have), but was an entertaining read.
Duchovny hints at reading this to a child, but the age range is this would be appropriate for is dubious. I can see a pre teen enjoying this with a parent, maybe. Cute, but not dazzling. If it weren't written by Fox Mulder, I wouldn't have picked it up.
Reviewed in the Stratford Gazette, July 2015
Stupid, inane collection of dumb comments in a weak attempt to empower animals. Don't bother wasting your time on this one.
is this available in an audiobook?